‘Elsinore’ gives Andrew Scott a powerful role, but its drama overplays the emotion

In Elsinore, Andrew Scott plays Scottish actor Ian Charleson as he performs Hamlet at Britain’s National Theatre while living with AIDS. Set in 1989, the film follows Ian between rehearsals and stays in the Royal Free Hospital’s AIDS ward.

In a review published November 20, 2026, NPR praised Scott’s performance but argued that director Simon Stone’s film too often pushes viewers toward emotions the actor can convey on his own. The review singles out a quiet hospital scene in which Ian prepares to greet visitors as an example of Scott’s restraint and force.

The rehearsal scenes fare especially well in NPR’s assessment. Ian memorizes lines, practices fight choreography and works alongside other actors; these practical demands give the film focus. The review also praises the dark humor among Ian’s friends. But it finds the score insistent, the repeated use of Hamlet’s best-known passages predictable, and shots of admiring audience members unnecessary.

David Dawson plays activist and filmmaker Derek Jarman, while Olivia Colman plays Ian’s doctor. NPR’s central judgment is that Elsinore has a remarkable lead performance—and would be more affecting if it trusted Scott and the story’s quieter moments.