Musk’s political influence through the lens of the Gilded Age

In reporting published on October 30, 2026, historians offered contrasting answers to a question with a long history in the United States: how much power can one wealthy individual wield over government?

David Nasaw, an emeritus history professor at the City University of New York and a biographer of steel magnate Andrew Carnegie, argued that Elon Musk’s influence is unprecedented. Media outlets including The Washington Post and CNN reported that Musk had donated more than $400 million to Republican causes ahead of the 2026 midterm elections. Musk’s companies, including SpaceX and Tesla, had also received more than $30 billion in federal contracts, subsidies, loans and tax credits over the years. Nasaw called for higher taxes on billionaires and limits on campaign spending. Musk did not reply to a request for comment.

Richard White, an emeritus history professor at Stanford University, offered a different comparison. He argued that J.P. Morgan wielded even greater influence in the late 19th century, pointing to the banker’s role in helping the U.S. through an 1895 financial crisis. That influence had limits: President Theodore Roosevelt later broke up Northern Securities, the railroad company Morgan had assembled.

Marian Tupy, a senior fellow at the Cato Institute, defended political spending as a constitutional right and argued that nonconformists such as Musk can advance innovation. White, meanwhile, said Musk’s reliance on government funding could leave him vulnerable to an unfriendly president and Congress.

For University of Texas at Austin historian H.W. Brands, the comparison reflects a recurring tension between democratic political equality and economic inequality. He noted that Progressive Era reforms followed the concentration of wealth and power during the Gilded Age, and suggested another period of democratic reform could follow the current one. That is his forecast, not an enacted reform.